I thoroughly enjoyed Watchmen when it hit the big screen earlier this year. Sure, it was very very dense and many of the nuances of the story as well as the storytelling techniques possible only with sequential art were lost in the translation to celluloid, but I thought director Zack Snyder (along with screenwriters David Hayter and Alex Tse) did a bang-up job with this adaptation. Click HERE to read more about my initial thoughts on the movie eight months ago.
Did I like the extra long Ultimate Cut? The answer is yes! The extra length allowed the story room to breath, although the movie still felt very dense. I had some trepidations with the inclusion of the Tales of the Black Freighter animated short to the movie would be weird, moving back and forth between live action footage with traditional 2D animation, but the transition was seamless and worked every bit as well as it did in the original comics.
I had not seen the Director's Cut, released on DVD and Blu-ray months ago. Along with the fact that I had only caught the original Theatrical Cut once eight months ago, I am hard pressed to tell exactly which are the new scenes, but the overall movie watching experience with the Ultimate Cut remains an enjoyable one.
This four-disc set is comes in a handsome and sturdy thick cardboard box, emblazoned with a pirate version of the Comedian's famous badge. I always thought this was an odd graphical choice, but I can see the economic and legal reasons for not using the smiley face. The rear of the box is adorned with more pirate imagery amidst with Rorschach's calling sign.


Opening the package (it was kept closed with a hidden magnet clasp) reveals an attractive graphic of the main heroes, and within the package is a cardboard slipcase housing three discs, with the Motion Comic disc stashed aside in a traditional Blu-ray clamshell. I suspect it is just leftover stock of the original release dumped here.


The cardboard slipcase features portraits of Ozymandias, The Comedian, and Nite Owl. Inside it are two Blu-ray discs (one each for the movie and the special features), and a DVD-ROM disc containing the Digital Copy. The passcode to download the license for the Digital Copy of the Theatrical Cut is found as a loose slip of paper.


Most of the special features from the previous Blu-ray release is included here, along with new audio commentaries by Zack Snyder and Dave Gibbons. Missing is the much acclaimed Maximum Movie Mode, which had Zack Snyder basically hosting a video tour of the movie and behind the scenes footage. Tales of the Black Freighter is not available as a separate feature as well, although thankfully the Behind The Hood mockumentary is included.
The VC-1 video encode looked superb on my 40" 1080p panel, although the Dolby TrueHD track was rather soft, the same problem I had with the DTS-HD MA track in the Big-Screen Edition of Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen. Beyond that, there is precious little to complain about the A/V presentation of the movie and it is comforting to know that even a 215 minute movie with a high resolution lossless audio track can fit on a 50GB BD-50 disc. Overall, I am very happy with the purchase and well worth the RM130 spent.




























































































